No Result
View All Result
Sunday, July 13, 2025
23 °c
Tripoli
24 ° Sat
24 ° Sun
  • Advertising
  • Contact
LibyaHerald
  • Home
  • Libya
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Magazine
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Register
SUBSCRIBE
  • Home
  • Libya
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Magazine
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
LibyaHerald
No Result
View All Result
Home Libya

Libya and the International Criminal Court – the issues explained

byMichel Cousins
October 24, 2012
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A

By Chris Stephen.

The ICC is currently considering whether Libya is competent to try the case of Saif Al-Islam Qaddafi.

Tripoli, 23 October:

Some time in the next days or weeks, three judges with black robes and white bibs sitting . . .[restrict]in a courtroom in The Hague, Netherlands, will make history.

They will rule on whether Libya is able to hold a fair trial for Saif Al-Islam Qaddafi and Abdullah Senussi, Libya’s former intelligence chief.

The decision by the International Criminal Court, whichever way it goes, promises to take international justice into unknown territory.

RELATED POSTS

Aldabaiba proposes new Road Map for holding elections, loans and land for youth and money for healthcare for war wounded

Cooperation agreements reached between Libyan and the Greek pharmaceutical and medical companies: Tripoli Chamber of Commerce

The ICC indicted the pair for war crimes and crimes against humanity in 2011, along with Saif’s late father, Muammar. The UN has given the ICC primacy in the case.

The judges must make a simple decision – can Libya guarantee it is “able or willing” to hold a fair trial? If not, the ICC will refuse permission for Libya to hold these trials and demand they are sent to The Hague.

First, a bit of history.

The ICC is not a UN court. It was designed by UN officials in the 1990s to replace temporary UN war crimes courts for Cambodia, East Timor, Rwanda, Sierra Leone and former Yugoslavia, the idea being to have a permanent world court.

But the idea was objected to by China, Russia and the United States, three of the five permanent members of the UN’s all-powerful security council.

Instead, the court came into being in 2002 as an independent organisation, controlled by its member states – now 121.

While many of the big powers dislike the court, many smaller nations support it. European Union states see it as an extension of their own justice systems. And new democracies, especially those in Africa and South America, joined as an insurance policy against the return of military juntas.

Although it has no formal connection to the UN, the UN Security Council is free to order the ICC into action. In 2005, the council did just that, regarding alleged crimes in Darfur. Last year it made the same order for Libya.

But Libya’s government says it wants to try Saif, arrested last November, and Senussi, extradited from Mauritania in September, on home soil.

In October, Libya made a formal challenge to the judges.

Despite the name, the “challenge” is something the court expects.  It is set up as a court of “last resort” with preference being for states to hold their own trials. But those trials have to be fair. And the decision on whether Libya makes that criterion is judicial, not political — although politics have swirled around it for months.

In January, Libyan justice minister Ali Khalifa Ashur told Reuters the ICC had “accepted” that Libya would try Saif. Within an hour, the ICC denied it.

When ICC officials were allowed to visit Saif, being kept in a secret location in the Jebel Nafusa town of Zintan in March, Xavier-Jean Keita, head of the ICC’s public defence office, complained in court documents that only female staff members were allowed to see him.

In the same documents he wrote that Dr Ahmed Gehani, Libya’s liaison with the ICC, said Saif was not being prosecuted for ICC crimes but for “alleged failure to have licenses for two camels, and cleaning of fish farms”.

In April, Libya launched its formal challenge to the ICC, hiring a top British human rights lawyer, Professor Philippe Sands, to make its case.

That same month, Ashur declared Libya was going ahead with its own trial, then set to be finished by June, before the elections – and before the ICC could decide on the challenge.

In June, with no sign of Saif going on trial, ICC officials made a second visit – and got arrested.

Libya accused Keita’s deputy, Melinda Taylor, of acting improperly when meeting Saif, and she and three colleagues were held for three weeks.

“Melinda Taylor handed over to the accused some documents and papers which compromise the national security of Libya,” said Prime Minister Abdurrahim Al-Kib. “These documents have nothing to do with the ICC mission.”

Keita said in court documents that Taylor had been “tricked” by having a guard described as “illiterate” placed in the room when she handed Saif a statement for him to sign.

“The guard, who is actually Ahmed Amer, a councillor who speaks several languages, was planted in the room to deliberately trick the delegation,” writes Keita in a report to the ICC. “He came into the room and started shouting that the statement was very dangerous, violated Libyan national security.”

Neither side has produced the documents to clear the matter up, but the affair further poisoned relations between Libya and the court, which had already complained that Saif’s isolation amounted to “torture.”

In August, Libya prosecution official Taha Naser Bara told the UK Sunday Telegraph it would hold Saif’s trial in September, again without waiting for an ICC decision.

In September, Libya said it was postponing the trial a third time so that evidence could be gleaned from Senussi, extradited from Mauritania to Tripoli that same month.

At the formal challenge hearing in October, ICC defence lawyers said Libya could not give Saif a fair trial. The court’s prosecution office insisted it could.

But it is with the judges that the decision rests. And they know that if they make the wrong decision, it will be the one they are remembered for, for decades to come.

One problem is that the ICC is new, and has few precedents to rely on. Kenya was refused such a challenge last year, but in different circumstances.

If the ICC decides Libya cannot guarantee fair trials, and Libya holds those trials anyway, the judges will complain to the UN Security Council, which ordered it into action in the first place.

Richard Dicker, head of international justice at Human Rights Watch in New York, argues that such a complaint would hurt Libya. “It would be a severe loss of credibility for the new Libyan government for them to put themselves in breach of a Security Council resolution.”

The Security Council could theoretically decide to punish Libya. It could do nothing. The five permanent members are divided over so many issues they may struggle to agree anything at all.

As with the decision of those three ICC judges, their reaction is impossible to predict.

Chris Stephen is the author of Judgement Day: The Trial of Slobodan Milosevic (Atlantic Monthly Press, New York, 2005)

  [/restrict]

Tags: featured

Related Posts

Attorney General orders arrests at Jumhouria bank branch for embezzlement
Libya

Attorney General provides update on investigation of incidents resulting from Tripoli 2025 armed clashes and demonstrations

July 11, 2025
GNU to take oath at Benghazi HoR session and budget to be approved at Tripoli session: GNU
Libya

Aldabaiba seeking long term partnership not interim solutions on combatting irregular migration

July 10, 2025
Acting Interior Minister Trabelsi taking steps to counter forged ID numbers and passports
Libya

There are 4 million irregular migrants in Libya: Interior Minister Trabelsi

July 10, 2025
GNU to take oath at Benghazi HoR session and budget to be approved at Tripoli session: GNU
Libya

Aldabaiba: Militias have become criminal gangs and a state within the state

July 9, 2025
Libya Herald exclusive: Responding to the prime minister’s call yesterday to the private sector and banks to do more, leading businessman Husni Bey responds
Business

Op-Ed: Reputational Damage Is Worse Than Losing Money

July 2, 2025
Libyan Russian Economic Forum starts in St. Petersburg
Libya

Libyan Russian Economic Forum starts in St. Petersburg

June 27, 2025
Next Post

Libya can build better future despite challenges says British minister

Two hospitalised as post-graduates continue KL embassy protest fast

ADVERTISEMENT

Top Stories

  • Benghazi port receives 398 containers of mixed goods, 25,000 tons of wheat, 28,500 tons of barley and 6,000 tons of cement

    All imports into Libya must be paid for through official bank transactions

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Libya Development and Reconstruction Fund signs contract with Turkey’s Ankamenia for maintenance of Benghazi University’s medical colleges

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • BP to reopen office in Libya, Shell discusses prospects for cooperation in oil field development‎

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Libyan olive oils win gold at Anatolian, Berlin and Japan 2025 international olive oil competitions

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Aldabaiba opens First Phase of Tripoli’s Third Ring Road

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
ADVERTISEMENT
LibyaHerald

The Libya Herald first appeared on 17 February 2012 – the first anniversary of the Libyan Revolution. Since then, it has become a favourite go-to source on news about Libya, for many in Libya and around the world, regularly attracting millions of hits.

Recent News

CBL workshop on ‎”The Role of the Banking Sector in Revitalising Stalled Housing Projects and Urban Development”‎ to be held in Tripoli on 13 July

Attorney General provides update on investigation of incidents resulting from Tripoli 2025 armed clashes and demonstrations

Sitemap

  • Why subscribe?
  • Terms & Conditions
  • FAQs
  • Copyright & Intellectual Property Rights
  • Subscribe now

Newsletters

    Be the first to know latest important news & events directly to your inbox.

    Sending ...

    By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

    © 2022 LibyaHerald - Powered by Sparx Solutions.

    Welcome Back!

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password? Sign Up

    Create New Account!

    Fill the forms below to register

    *By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In
    No Result
    View All Result
    • Login
    • Sign Up
    • Libya
    • Business
    • Advertising
    • About us
    • BusinessEye Magazine
    • Letters
    • Features
    • Why subscribe?
    • FAQs
    • Contact

    © 2022 LibyaHerald - Powered by Sparx Solutions.

    This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.