No Result
View All Result
Tuesday, September 26, 2023
24 °c
Tripoli
24 ° Wed
25 ° Thu
25 ° Fri
24 ° Sat
  • Advertising
  • Contact
LibyaHerald
 
  • Home
  • Libya
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Magazine
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Register
SUBSCRIBE
  • Home
  • Libya
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Magazine
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
LibyaHerald
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

Opinion: A State in Purgatory – Libya and the Logic of Statelessness

bySami Zaptia
December 1, 2013
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
12
SHARES
52
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Sherine N. El Taraboulsi.

Oxford, England, 1 December 2013:

Libya is making headlines again and not with the best of news. Violence . . .[restrict]has erupted in both the East and the West with rising numbers of casualties and no end of instability in sight; a sense of frustration and exhaustion seems to dominate the public realm.

Libya is in purgatory both literally and figuratively. It is paying for the sins of the past, some committed by its own people but mostly committed by forces that sought to control its resources without an understanding of the specificity of its context.

As Michael Ondaatje’s The English Patient describes it: “All I desired was to walk upon such an earth that had no maps”. It is the land that has no maps and that is Libya’s curse and blessing; without maps, it could be easily violated but it also remains the land of possibility. Today, it is literally stuck between a launched but incomplete state building process and the entrenched statelessness of the past.

RELATED POSTS

Tripoli in relative calm after arrested 444th Brigade commander Hamza released to neutral security party

Minister of Labour and Rehabilitation participates in workshop on the National Project for Rehabilitation and Integration

There is a logic to statelessness in Libya, unlike what many would think – it is not random. There are structures of statelessness that need to be unpacked and restructured towards building the new Libya. Instead of restructuring, the tendency is almost always directed to effacement.

Tribal confederations are an example; for 20 years the Ottomans sought to defeat the tribal confederations of the Mahamid and Awlad Sulayman in Tripolitania and Fezzan, the Italians perceived the Libyans as a monolith non grata composed of non-descript multiple tribes, so much so, that by the time the Italian occupation ended, Libya was left with only seven university graduates.

The Italians left Libya with an infrastructure of roads but without an infrastructure of a state, and fought whatever kernel of state building there was. Libya’s history is the story of multiple rounds of state building and state effacement; processes get launched and then get effaced. The reasons are various but a common theme seems to be a lack of understanding of the sociocultural context and the illusion that change and state building is top down.

More than two years after the death of Qaddafi, Libyans are still struggling to find peace and security. The GNC, formerly hailed as a success on the path towards building a democratic state, could not meaningfully contribute to resolving the crisis – It tried but it was not heard.

The example of Tripoli is instructive; it was only with the meeting of the local councils that a way out was charted. This is not the end of the revolutionary fervor in Libya, nor the end of the state building process. This is, however, a severe setback and there are some lessons learned that need to be taken into consideration as we go forward.

Myths, Realities and Priorities

There are a number of myths about Libya that need to be expunged for a serious evaluation of the situation and to be able to strategically think of state formation.  Those include:

Libya is stateless

Conventional statehood wisdom can easily discount Libya as a non-state or stateless country. This overlooks indigenous and local structures of governance that can be replicated at the macro level. As Douglass North puts it, “states are organizations of organizations”; organizations are groups of people structured around a specific need or cause.

Tribal confederations are one of the oldest forms of organizations in Libya, they have their own systems of adjudicating differences, their own trade structures and those warrant close examination, not as an impediment – which they can be and have been – but more along the lines of an opportunity towards building a state out of local models.

A state will never be built until it is in the best interest of leading tribes to give away some of their privileges in exchange for state institutions that integrate Libya within the global realm.

Libya has no national identity

Libya has not been allowed to develop a unified national imaginary; it lacked the institutions that would help them develop that. Waves of colonialism and its geography composed of wide expanse of dry desert have not allowed Libyans to know or meet one another.

It was only in 2012 that Libyans from the East actually got to be unified with Libyans in the West towards one cause. Under Qaddafi, no institutions or structures were developed to allow that to happen; Qaddafi equated Libyan national identity with nothing but himself. The world only knew Libya through Qaddafi and so did the Libyans themselves.

This has, however, changed. Two processes have been launched that point towards the existence of a national imaginary: a revisiting of Libyan history by Libyans themselves and a rise in civil society organizations that are increasingly communicating with one another. Libya today has a national identity in the making.

Libya has no real civil society

Libya’s safety net seems to be its very diverse and active civil society. Under Qaddafi, civil society was monopolized for propaganda purposes; the Qaddafi foundation was used as an exterior to cover atrocities taking place back home and the rise of Saif Al Islam Qaddafi came hand in hand with the rise of the foundation.

But there were still local structures of welfare that existed, community organizations did exist, keeping a low profile and not formalized by the state nevertheless. Libya has a long history of waqf (endowment) which, interestingly enough, contributed to the rise of the Senusi Kingdom. All waqf was later nationalized by Qaddafi as did Nasser in Egypt.

Today, hundreds of organizations have mushroomed across the country and have formed coalitions and there role will prove central in the building of the new Libyan state.

Priorities

Controlling the Violence: Ending the violence completely, in the very short term, seems to be far fetched under the circumstances, but controlling it is a necessity. This can only happen with the consolidation of community as well as government efforts.

The unregulated contracting of militias has contributed to the expansion of violence as well as enhancing regional divides; this needs to be addressed. Numbers reached over 200,000 fighters on the payroll.  Not all of the fighters were part of the war against Qaddafi, a shocking number especially for a population of six million.

Change needs to emerge organically from the bottom-up: Tools and mechanisms that facilitate meaningful and better communication on critical issues between the GNC and local entities needs to be developed; one will not replace the other but both are complimentary to one another in the process of change.

A new generation of Libyan policymakers needs to emerge: The current government should think long-term and put in place strategies towards graduating a new generation of policymakers; training Libyan youth into developing ideas to policy seems essential.

International donors and organizations are advised to invest more in understanding the local context than in launching new programs: Libya is opening up to the world after decades of isolation, so there is a need for cooperation. It is how this cooperation happens that is important. International actors need to listen to their Libyan counterparts as equals and recognize that uninformed interventions can be damaging.

 

Sherine N. El Taraboulsi is a DPhil (PhD) Candidate at the Department of International Development, Queen Elizabeth House (QEH), the University of Oxford.

  [/restrict]

 
Tags: civil societyGNCItalianmilitiasOttomanQaddafistate-buildingtribes
Share5Tweet3Share1

Related Posts

Libya

OpEd: And exactly how safe is Tripoli?

January 10, 2018
OpEd: Turkey’s foreign minister on tomorrow’s Istanbul conflict resolution conference
Libya

OpEd: Turkey’s foreign minister on tomorrow’s Istanbul conflict resolution conference

July 31, 2017
Op-Ed: Playing the Trump card in Libya
Libya

Op-Ed: Playing the Trump card in Libya

November 19, 2016
Opinion

Op-Ed: Libya after the spin and deception

December 21, 2015
Opinion

Op-Ed: The Art of Avoiding Dialogue

December 16, 2015
Opinion

Op-Ed: Libya’s Article 13 – disagreeing over the political agreement

October 12, 2015
Next Post

Air Force officer shot dead in front of son in Benghazi

Traffic chaos in the wake of the floods

 

Advertise on LibyaHerald

Reach thousands of our site visitors daily

240 x 400px

Advertise Here
ADVERTISEMENT

Top Stories

  • UN’s Derna overview: Officially, only 3,958 confirmed dead and 40,000 displaced

    UN’s Derna overview: Officially, only 3,958 confirmed dead and 40,000 displaced

    76 shares
    Share 35 Tweet 17
  • Civil Aviation Authority concludes meetings with Turkish Civil Aviation team inspecting airports for possible return of Turkish airliners

    65 shares
    Share 30 Tweet 15
  • EU Copernicus satellite images of Flood Daniel hit Libya released

    58 shares
    Share 26 Tweet 13
  • Eastern Libyan government calls for international reconstruction conference for Flood Daniel hit areas

    61 shares
    Share 33 Tweet 12
  • Greater Tripoli Municipalities discuss the region’s main river valley, sound alarm of possible disaster

    100 shares
    Share 72 Tweet 12
LibyaHerald

The Libya Herald first appeared on 17 February 2012 – the first anniversary of the Libyan Revolution. Since then, it has become a favourite go-to source on news about Libya, for many in Libya and around the world, regularly attracting millions of hits.

Recent News

Italian Cabinet gives green light for a state of emergency to intervene in Libya, allocates € 5 million

Internal Security arrests NOC Chairman’s Office Manager for corruption in supply of medicines for Derna and its environs

Sitemap

  • Why subscribe?
  • Terms & Conditions
  • FAQs
  • Copyright & Intellectual Property Rights
  • Subscribe now

Newsletters

    Be the first to know latest important news & events directly to your inbox.

    Sending ...

    By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

    © 2022 LibyaHerald - Powered by Sparx Solutions.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Login
    • Sign Up
    • Cart
    • Libya
    • Business
    • Advertising
    • About us
    • BusinessEye Magazine
    • Letters
    • Features
    • Why subscribe?
    • FAQs
    • Contact

    © 2022 LibyaHerald - Powered by Sparx Solutions.

    Welcome Back!

    Sign In with Facebook
    Sign In with Linked In
    OR

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password? Sign Up

    Create New Account!

    Sign Up with Facebook
    Sign Up with Linked In
    OR

    Fill the forms bellow to register

    *By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In
    This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
    Are you sure want to unlock this post?
    Unlock left : 0
    Are you sure want to cancel subscription?