No Result
View All Result
Monday, June 5, 2023
26 °c
Tripoli
24 ° Tue
22 ° Wed
22 ° Thu
24 ° Fri
  • Advertising
  • Contact
LibyaHerald
 
  • Home
  • Libya
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Magazine
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Register
SUBSCRIBE
  • Home
  • Libya
  • Business
  • Opinion
  • Magazine
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Register
No Result
View All Result
LibyaHerald
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

The change in prime minister: constitutionally, the system worked perfectly

byGeorge Grant
October 22, 2012
Reading Time: 3 mins read
A A
The change in prime minister: constitutionally, the system worked perfectly

Abushagur out, Zidan in.

12
SHARES
50
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Lorianne Updike Toler.

Abushagur out, Zidan in. Constitutionally sound.

New York City, 22 October:

The quick change in Libyan prime minister-elect from Mustafa Abushagur to Ali Zidan within . . .[restrict]the past month has many questioning whether the temporary parliamentary structures put in place by the National Transitional Council are sound.

If a problem does exist, however, it is not a function of design error, but the expectation that the General National Congress (GNC) and the new government should operate like other parliamentary systems.

This editorial will investigate those expectations compared to the intended structure of the GNC in suggesting a recalibration of expectations that appropriately considers the role that separation of powers and political parties can and should play in Libya’s existing political structures and in the new Constitution.

RELATED POSTS

Aldabaiba proposes new Road Map for holding elections, loans and land for youth and money for healthcare for war wounded

Cooperation agreements reached between Libyan and the Greek pharmaceutical and medical companies: Tripoli Chamber of Commerce

In unseating Abushagur through a vote of no confidence after his proposed government was rejected, and in electing Zidan one week later, the GNC operated with complete fidelity to the Constitutional Declaration of 3 August 2011.  This, in and of itself, is a triumph for Libyans.  It demonstrates to the world commitment to the rule of law and to constitutionalism.  (It may, for instance, be positively compared to transitional processes in Egypt, which have been marked by challenges to their interim constitutional documents and procedural irregularities.)  Although unsettling to the country’s hopes that a new government will quickly solve pressing security issues, the system functioned exactly as it ought.

Libyans, by design of the 3 August Constitutional Declaration, have determined that parties should play a lesser role in the makeup of the GNC.  Only 80 of 200 parliamentary seats were open to election by party ticket in July, the rest being reserved for various independent candidates from Libya’s three regions.

The GNC’s structure was thus rendered fundamentally different from most other parliamentary systems, wherein all seats are determined by party vote.  Such structural differences between the GNC and other, more traditional parliamentary structures, produces real differences in the election of prime ministers and the formation of governments.

For example, in traditional parliamentary structures such as in the United Kingdom, winning the most votes in an election produces a majority in Parliament for a given party. This majority is then able to elect a prime minister, who also relies on this majority to approve of his or her government.

In Libya’s 7 July elections, however, the party winning the most seats (39), the National Forces Alliance, captured only 19.5% of the total GNC membership of 200 because of the limitation on party participation. Abushagur, even if he had come from the NFA, would thus have been unable to rely on any kind of majority to approve his government. It is little wonder he did not meet with success.

Rather than become frustrated with recent events or jump to judgment, the country should instead realign expectations: if Libya’s political structure is fundamentally different, then it cannot adopt any other country’s way of doing politics, or expect that political systems will operate in similar fashion.

Instead, Libyan leaders should seek to understand how their unique structure impacts the formation and execution of political functions, the resultant strengths of such a structure, its challenges, and whether and in what ways the system may be improved under a new Constitution.

Deepened understanding may be realised by reviewing two underlying principles at play in recent events, that of the function and role of political parties and regional interests and the division and distribution of powers between branches of government, both historically and in comparative perspective.  Follow-on articles within this series will do just that.

Lorianne Updike Toler is the president of Lorianne Updike Toler consulting and the founding president of The Constitutional Sources Project in the United States. [/restrict]

 
Tags: featured
Share5Tweet3Share1

Related Posts

Libya

OpEd: And exactly how safe is Tripoli?

January 10, 2018
OpEd: Turkey’s foreign minister on tomorrow’s Istanbul conflict resolution conference
Libya

OpEd: Turkey’s foreign minister on tomorrow’s Istanbul conflict resolution conference

July 31, 2017
Op-Ed: Playing the Trump card in Libya
Libya

Op-Ed: Playing the Trump card in Libya

November 19, 2016
Opinion

Op-Ed: Libya after the spin and deception

December 21, 2015
Opinion

Op-Ed: The Art of Avoiding Dialogue

December 16, 2015
Opinion

Op-Ed: Libya’s Article 13 – disagreeing over the political agreement

October 12, 2015
Next Post

Libya needs a weapons collection policy that can work

Libyan women in Rome to look at women's rights

 

Advertise on LibyaHerald

Reach thousands of our site visitors daily

240 x 400px

Advertise Here
ADVERTISEMENT

Top Stories

  • State recognised militia and Libyan Army clash in central Tripoli

    State recognised militia and Libyan Army clash in central Tripoli

    244 shares
    Share 98 Tweet 61
  • HB Group opens Apple authorised I-Shop reseller in Tripoli’s Siyahia

    68 shares
    Share 27 Tweet 17
  • Members of illegal organizations given imprisonment and death sentences by Misrata Criminal Court

    56 shares
    Share 22 Tweet 14
  • Sirte Oil Company’s smart fields give it higher efficiency, more accurate real-time data for timely decisions

    49 shares
    Share 20 Tweet 12
  • The International Conference on Arbitration in Libya – held in Tripoli with international participation

    43 shares
    Share 17 Tweet 11
LibyaHerald

The Libya Herald first appeared on 17 February 2012 – the first anniversary of the Libyan Revolution. Since then, it has become a favourite go-to source on news about Libya, for many in Libya and around the world, regularly attracting millions of hits.

Recent News

On National Information Technology Day, the mini-satellite project CubeSat was launched

Ministry of Industry provides support to the Industrial Research Centre

Sitemap

  • Why subscribe?
  • Terms & Conditions
  • FAQs
  • Copyright & Intellectual Property Rights
  • Subscribe now

Newsletters

    Be the first to know latest important news & events directly to your inbox.

    Sending ...

    By signing up, I agree to our TOS and Privacy Policy.

    © 2022 LibyaHerald - Powered by Sparx Solutions.

    No Result
    View All Result
    • Login
    • Sign Up
    • Cart
    • Libya
    • Business
    • Advertising
    • About us
    • BusinessEye Magazine
    • Letters
    • Features
    • Why subscribe?
    • FAQs
    • Contact

    © 2022 LibyaHerald - Powered by Sparx Solutions.

    Welcome Back!

    Sign In with Facebook
    Sign In with Linked In
    OR

    Login to your account below

    Forgotten Password? Sign Up

    Create New Account!

    Sign Up with Facebook
    Sign Up with Linked In
    OR

    Fill the forms bellow to register

    *By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
    All fields are required. Log In

    Retrieve your password

    Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

    Log In
    This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
    Are you sure want to unlock this post?
    Unlock left : 0
    Are you sure want to cancel subscription?